A few of us here at FOH are Criterion Collections lovers (just take a look at our header photo). Pouring over the extras and drooling over the remastered prints excites us more than the average person. While Criterion makes some missteps from time to time link, link, I think they do a heck of a job selecting their films.
In a dream world Criterion would call me up and have me pick out a few films for them to polish up so here is my list:
